How Dangerous Is It? Check Now → Is Your Home Safe? Take the Audit →
Comprehensive Comparison Guide

Toxic Food Comparison:
What Kills Dogs vs. Cats

Side-by-side severity rankings for every toxic substance in our database. See which toxins are more dangerous for dogs, which are worse for cats, and what kills both — in one chart.

Dr Brahmsy's Pet First Aid Kit for Dogs & Cats

Keep a pet first aid kit at home

Having first aid supplies ready before an emergency is something most veterinary professionals recommend.

This pet first aid kit includes commonly recommended emergency supplies. Having supplies ready before you need them makes a difference.

Get the Pet First Aid Kit →

How to Read This Chart

1 Mild

GI upset, recover at home

2 Moderate

Vet visit likely needed

3 Severe

Emergency vet required

4 FATAL RISK

Can kill without treatment

Complete Toxicity Comparison Table

Substance Dog Severity Cat Severity Onset Vet Cost More Dangerous For
Grapes and Raisins FATAL severe 6–12 hours $500–$5000 Dogs
Onions and Garlic severe FATAL 1–5 days $300–$5000 Cats
Xylitol (Birch Sugar) FATAL moderate 30 minutes – 12 hours $500–$8000 Dogs
Antifreeze (Ethylene Glycol) FATAL FATAL 30 minutes – 12 hours $500–$8000 Both
Ibuprofen (Advil) FATAL FATAL 2–6 hours $300–$6000 Both
Rat Poison (Bromethalin) FATAL FATAL 24–72 hours (may be delayed) $500–$6000 Both
Sago Palm FATAL FATAL 2–12 hours $1000–$8000 Both
Lilies (All Species) — FATAL 2–12 hours $500–$10000 Cats
Acetaminophen (Tylenol) — FATAL 1–4 hours $500–$6000 Cats
Dog Flea Medication (Permethrin) — FATAL 1–12 hours (varies by exposure route) $300–$4000 Cats
Peanut Butter (Xylitol Risk) FATAL — 30–60 minutes (if xylitol present) $50–$5000 Dogs
Tylenol (Acetaminophen) severe FATAL 1–4 hours $300–$5000 Cats
Slugs and Snails (Lungworm) FATAL — 1–4 weeks for symptoms $100–$4000 Dogs
Raw Salmon (Salmon Poisoning) FATAL mild 5-7 days $300–$3000 Dogs
String, Yarn, and Thread (Linear Foreign Body) — FATAL Hours to 2 days $800–$6000 Cats
Blue-Green Algae (Cyanobacteria) FATAL — 15 minutes to 24 hours $500–$8000 Dogs
Slug Bait (Metaldehyde) FATAL critical Within hours $0–$0 Dogs
Hops (Homebrewing) FATAL — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Fluorouracil Topical Cream (5-FU) FATAL — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Minoxidil (Rogaine) — FATAL Varies $0–$0 Cats
Fly Bait (Methomyl) FATAL — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Chocolate severe severe 6–12 hours $300–$3500 Both
Caffeine (Coffee/Tea) severe severe 1–2 hours $300–$4000 Both
Alcohol severe severe 30–60 minutes $300–$4000 Both
Yeast Dough severe — 30–60 minutes $500–$5000 Dogs
Salt (Sodium Chloride) severe severe 1–12 hours $300–$4000 Both
Essential Oils (Tea Tree, Eucalyptus) — severe 2–12 hours (varies by exposure route) $200–$4000 Cats
Azaleas and Rhododendrons — severe 1–6 hours $200–$3000 Cats
Rhubarb severe — 2-8 hours $400–$4000 Dogs
Pennies (Zinc Toxicity) severe moderate 1-3 days $800–$5000 Dogs
Moldy Food (Tremorgenic Mycotoxins) severe severe 30 minutes to 2 hours $300–$3000 Both
Batteries (Alkaline and Lithium) severe severe Immediate (burns within 15-30 minutes) $500–$5000 Both
Vitamin D (Supplements and Rodenticide) severe severe 12-36 hours $500–$5000 Both
Essential Oils (Tea Tree, Eucalyptus, Pennyroyal, Wintergreen, Clove) severe — — $300–$3000 Dogs
Cooked Bones severe moderate Hours to days (depends on damage) $500–$8000 Dogs
Human Antidepressants (SSRIs like Prozac, Zoloft, Lexapro) — severe 1-4 hours $400–$4000 Cats
Daffodils and Narcissus — severe 15 minutes to 6 hours $300–$3000 Cats
Chocolate Chip Cookies severe — 2-6 hours $300–$4000 Dogs
Baby Food (Onion Powder Risk) — severe 1-5 days $200–$3000 Cats
Essential Oil Diffuser (Airborne Toxicity) — severe 30 minutes to 12 hours $200–$3000 Cats
Azalea severe severe Varies $0–$0 Both
Black Walnut severe — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Rhododendron severe severe Varies $0–$0 Both
Cocoa Mulch severe — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Star Fruit (Carambola) severe — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Hyacinth Bulbs severe moderate Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Tobacco (Cigarettes and Cigars) severe — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Tinsel and Holiday Garland — severe Varies $0–$0 Cats
Ivermectin (Horse Dewormer Paste) severe — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Mosquito Repellent with DEET moderate severe Varies $0–$0 Cats
Benzocaine Oral Gels (Orajel, Teething Gel) moderate severe Varies $0–$0 Cats
Cane Toads and Colorado River Toads critical severe Varies $0–$0 Cats
Wintergreen and Birch Oil (Methyl Salicylate) — severe Varies $0–$0 Cats
Chicken Bones severe — Hours to days $200–$6000 Dogs
Brownies severe — 6–12 hours $300–$5000 Dogs
Dental Floss severe — Hours to days $200–$7000 Dogs
Macadamia Nuts moderate — 3–12 hours $150–$2000 Dogs
Marijuana (Cannabis) moderate moderate 30–60 minutes (edibles may be longer) $200–$3000 Both
Pothos (Devil's Ivy) moderate moderate Immediate to 2 hours $0–$1200 Both
Aloe Vera moderate moderate 6-12 hours $0–$1500 Both
Tulips and Daffodils — moderate 1–6 hours $0–$2000 Cats
Garlic Bread moderate — 1–5 days for anemia signs $200–$3500 Dogs
Nutmeg moderate — 3–8 hours $200–$2000 Dogs
Tomato Plant (Leaves and Stems) moderate — 2-8 hours $100–$1500 Dogs
Coffee Grounds and Coffee Beans moderate — 1-2 hours $200–$2500 Dogs
Ice Cream (Xylitol/Lactose) moderate — 30 minutes to 6 hours $0–$3000 Dogs
Edible Marijuana (Weed Edibles) critical moderate 30 minutes to 3 hours $300–$3000 Cats
Dog Food (Long-Term Feeding to Cats) — moderate Weeks to months (chronic) $0–$1000 Cats
Monstera (Swiss Cheese Plant) moderate moderate Immediate $0–$1200 Both
Peace Lily (Spathiphyllum) — moderate Immediate $0–$400 Cats
English Ivy moderate moderate Immediate to 6 hours $0–$1000 Both
Philodendron — moderate Immediate $0–$300 Cats
Dracaena (Corn Plant) — moderate Hours $0–$500 Cats
Tulip moderate — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Avocado Plant — moderate Varies $0–$0 Cats
Corn Plant (Dracaena) moderate — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Persimmons (Seeds and Pits) moderate — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Plums and Plum Pits moderate — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Elderberries (Raw and Unripe) moderate — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Geraniums moderate — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Jerky Treats (Imported Chicken) moderate — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Ginkgo Biloba Seeds moderate — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Blue Cheese (Roquefortine C) moderate — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Excessive Liver for Cats (Vitamin A) — moderate Varies $0–$0 Cats
Ant Bait Traps (Abamectin) — moderate Varies $0–$0 Cats
Dead Bird moderate — Hours to 3 days $150–$4000 Dogs
Frog or Toad moderate — Minutes to 1 hour $100–$4000 Dogs
Acorns moderate — Hours to 2 days $100–$3000 Dogs
Avocado mild — 6–12 hours $150–$3000 Dogs
Spinach mild — Days to weeks (cumulative) $50–$500 Dogs
Milk and Dairy Products — mild 8-12 hours $0–$800 Cats
Glow Sticks and Glow Jewelry — mild Immediate (seconds to minutes) $0–$300 Cats
Tuna (Excessive Human-Grade Canned Tuna) — mild Weeks to months (cumulative) $50–$1000 Cats
Silica Gel Packets (Desiccant Packets) mild — 1-6 hours $0–$2000 Dogs
Flea and Tick Collars (Permethrin) — critical 2-12 hours $300–$3000
Xylitol Gum critical — 30-60 minutes $500–$5000
Nut Butter (Xylitol Risk) critical — 30-60 minutes $500–$5000
Tuna Water (Excessive) — mild Weeks to months $0–$300 Cats
Lily Pollen (Airborne Exposure) — critical 2-12 hours $1000–$8000
ZZ Plant (Zamioculcas Zamiifolia) — mild Minutes to hours $0–$200 Cats
Fiddle Leaf Fig — mild Minutes $0–$150 Cats
Rubber Plant (Ficus Elastica) mild mild Immediate to 6 hours $0–$600 Both
Schefflera (Umbrella Plant) — mild Minutes to hours $0–$150 Cats
Peony (Paeonia) mild mild 2-12 hours $0–$600 Both
Peace Lily mild — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
ZZ Plant mild — Varies $0–$0 Dogs
Tomato Plant — mild Varies $0–$0 Cats
Gorilla Glue (Polyurethane Adhesive) critical — Varies $0–$0
Begonias — mild Varies $0–$0 Cats
Pine Oil Cleaner — critical Varies $0–$0
Dog NSAID Chews in Cats (Carprofen and Rimadyl) — critical Varies $0–$0
Bee mild — Minutes to 1 hour $0–$1500 Dogs
Honey mild — Within hours if any $0–$300 Dogs
Deer Poop mild — 1–7 days $0–$500 Dogs
Banana Peel mild — Hours to 2 days $0–$3000 Dogs
Ant Bait Traps mild — Hours to 2 days $0–$2500 Dogs

Key Findings: What's More Dangerous for Dogs vs. Cats

More Dangerous for Dogs

  • • Grapes & Raisins — Unpredictable kidney failure; no known safe dose
  • • Xylitol (Birch Sugar) — Rapid hypoglycemia and liver failure
  • • Blue-Green Algae — Can kill within 20 minutes of drinking contaminated water
  • • Raw Salmon — Fatal Salmon Poisoning Disease unique to canids
  • • Macadamia Nuts — Neurological toxicity unique to dogs

More Dangerous for Cats

  • • Lilies (ALL species) — Lethal kidney failure from licking pollen; cats only
  • • Dog Flea Medication (Permethrin) — Lethal seizures; cats lack the enzyme to process it
  • • Acetaminophen (Tylenol) — Destroys red blood cells; one pill can kill a cat
  • • Essential Oils — Cats' livers cannot metabolize terpenes at all
  • • String/Yarn — Linear foreign body obstruction; cats are uniquely prone
Pet Emergency Handbook

The Book Most Pet Owners Buy After Their First Emergency Visit

This pet emergency handbook covers every poisoning scenario with step-by-step instructions. It's the book that saves you from Googling in a panic at 2 AM.

Get the Emergency Handbook — Know Before It Happens →

Frequently Asked Questions

What food is most toxic to dogs?

Grapes and raisins are among the most lethal foods for dogs because they cause acute kidney failure with no predictable dose threshold. Xylitol (birch sugar) is equally dangerous, causing rapid hypoglycemia and liver failure. Both can be fatal from small amounts.

What food is most toxic to cats?

Lilies are the single most deadly substance for cats. Even licking pollen off their fur or drinking water from a lily vase causes fatal kidney failure. A single Tylenol pill can also kill a cat. Dog flea medication containing permethrin causes lethal seizures in cats.

Are there toxins that are dangerous for both dogs and cats?

Yes. Chocolate, antifreeze (ethylene glycol), sago palm, and marijuana are all severely toxic to both species. Always check individual pages for species-specific severity, as the same substance can affect dogs and cats differently.

How quickly do I need to act if my pet ate something toxic?

Immediately. For many toxins (antifreeze, blue-green algae, lilies), irreversible damage begins within hours. Call your vet or get to an emergency clinic right away. Do not wait for symptoms to appear — by the time you see symptoms, significant damage may already be done.

Not Sure What Your Pet Ate?

Use our calculator to get an instant severity assessment based on substance, pet weight, and amount consumed.

Use the Severity Calculator Now →
Pet First Aid Kit

1 in 3 pet owners face a poisoning emergency.

Most veterinary professionals recommend keeping basic first aid supplies on hand.